School Board turns sour
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
School Board turns sour
A meeting meant to honor Director, Chair ends in accusations of Impropriety
Scott County School board met last week where after a presentation by Rep. Kelly Keisling, the board found themselves the subject of two concerned parents who sought to address an incident of alleged inappropriate behavior by a school staff member and their teenage child.
By Shane Gilreath
SCN Contributing Editor
[email protected]
A Scott County Board of Education meeting intended to celebrate longtime service instead turned tense Thursday evening, as parents confronted school officials over allegations involving a school employee and a 14-year-old student. Because of the age of the child involved, SCN has elected not to identify the student or the student’s parents.
The meeting initially centered on honoring Director of Schools Bill Hall, who is preparing to retire in June after years leading the district. State Rep. Kelly Keisling was on hand in Huntsville to present Hall with a Joint House Resolution recognizing his service to Tennessee students.
“Bill instilled work ethic and character into his student athletes, even after his formal coaching career came to a close,” Keisling said while presenting Hall with a legislative license plate commemorating his career.
Keisling also recognized Board Chair Llew Stanley for earning a Level V distinction through the Tennessee School Boards Association, an honor recognizing extensive training in governance, education law, leadership, and advocacy beyond standard board requirements.
The tone of the meeting shifted dramatically, however, when parents addressed the board regarding what they described as “concerning messages” exchanged between their child and a school social worker. According to the parents, the messages were first brought to the attention of a school principal, who then informed Hall. Hall stated that he contacted legal counsel and that the matter was referred to law enforcement. The parents alleged they were told the employee would immediately be placed on leave pending an investigation.
Hall acknowledged during questioning that he did not inform the school board the same day the allegations surfaced. He also confirmed the employee was allowed to resign rather than being terminated, which became a contentious issue with the parents.
“Our kids weren’t important enough for you to take care of this immediately,” the mother charged. “Instead, you continued to let (the employee) work.”
Despite the emotional nature of the exchange, both parents remained composed as they questioned administrators and board members about the timeline of events and the district’s response.
“When you have a social worker inside a school being investigated for child grooming, why is it not important to take care of it that day?” the mother asked. “Two days after this woman was still working.”
County Attorney John Beaty – who also advises the school district – defended the district’s handling of the matter.
“There is a requirement, as all of us know, to report anything that could be a criminal matter,” Beaty said, adding that the Scott County Sheriff’s Office had been contacted. Beaty is correct in that assessment. According to Tennessee Code Annotated § 37-1-403, any person with knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or child sexual abuse to report it immediately to authorities. In that, Tennessee is broader than many states as every adult is effectively a mandated reporter, not just teachers or counselors. However, the law applies directly to teachers, school officials, school personnel, administrators, as well as boards of education, and requires immediate action when suspected child abuse or sexual abuse is possible, reporting to both the Department of Children’s Services and law enforcement under the same coded law.
“The school system did exactly what it should have done,” Beaty went on to say, telling the concerned parents that protocols were followed, which seems to be the case, despite the questioning of timeframe.
SCN has learned that the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI) is involved in the case, and according to public statements from the child’s mother, the communications between the staff member and child did not escalate into a physical relationship.
Growing frustrated, the child’s father closed with an emotional rebuke aimed at those involved in handling the matter.
“When you get home tonight, knock all that thick layer of dust off your Bible and go to Matthew 18:5-6,” he said. “Sit there and make your little face and nod your head, but go and read it, because you need prayers just as much as anyone does.”
Concerns surrounding student grooming and staff misconduct have received growing statewide attention in recent years. A 2024 federal review found dozens of cases involving alleged staff-to-student sexual harassment and assault within Memphis-Shelby County Schools alone. Neighboring McCreary County, Kentucky, also saw a former assistant superintendent sentenced to federal prison in a separate case involving misconduct.
